Should we go with quartz or granite for kitchen counters? I've heard that quartz doesn't hold up great to heat from pots?

Both quartz and granite are excellent choices for Calgary kitchens, but they have different strengths. Your concern about quartz and heat is valid but often overstated - while quartz can be damaged by extreme heat (300°F+), it's rare in normal cooking unless you place a scorching hot pot directly from the stove onto the surface.

Quartz advantages include being non-porous (no sealing required), extremely consistent in pattern and color, and highly resistant to stains and bacteria. It's engineered from 90-95% natural quartz crystals bound with resins, making it incredibly durable for daily use. The main heat limitation comes from the resin binders, which can discolor or crack under extreme temperatures. However, this is easily avoided with trivets or hot pads - a good practice regardless of countertop material.

Granite offers superior heat resistance since it's pure natural stone that can handle hot pots and pans without damage. Each slab has unique patterns and natural beauty that many homeowners prefer. However, granite is porous and requires sealing every 1-2 years to prevent stains and bacteria absorption. It can also chip more easily than quartz, especially around edges and corners.

For Calgary kitchens specifically, both materials perform well in our climate. The extreme temperature swings from chinooks don't affect interior countertops, and both materials handle the dry winter air without issues. Calgary's hard water won't stain either surface when properly maintained.

Cost considerations in the Greater Calgary market typically see quartz ranging from $80-150 per square foot installed, while granite runs $70-130 per square foot installed. Premium slabs of either material can exceed these ranges. Quartz tends to have more predictable pricing since it's manufactured, while granite pricing varies significantly based on the specific slab's rarity and origin.

Professional installation is crucial for both materials. The fabrication requires specialized tools and experience, and improper installation voids warranties. Most reputable countertop fabricators in Calgary offer both materials and can show you samples in their showrooms.

Bottom line: If you frequently place hot items directly on counters and prefer natural stone's unique character, granite might be your choice. If you want lower maintenance, consistent appearance, and don't mind using trivets for hot items, quartz is excellent. Both will serve Calgary families well for decades with proper care.

Find experienced countertop fabricators and kitchen renovation contractors in our Calgary directory to see samples and get detailed quotes for your specific project.